tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post7165552443121239641..comments2024-03-21T00:34:35.359-07:00Comments on Every Bob Dylan Song: Bob Dylan Song #173: Tangled Up in BlueTonyhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/12613923038816299394noreply@blogger.comBlogger22125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-42323152271991441382019-10-24T06:32:09.414-07:002019-10-24T06:32:09.414-07:00makasih gan buat infonya dan semoga bermanfaatmakasih gan buat infonya dan semoga bermanfaatistanaimpian2http://istanaimpian2.livenoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-43087278914231621172019-10-24T06:31:10.356-07:002019-10-24T06:31:10.356-07:00keren mas buat infonya dan salam sukses selalukeren mas buat infonya dan salam sukses selalufun88loginhttp://fun88login.netnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-36219346338780164552019-10-24T06:30:31.676-07:002019-10-24T06:30:31.676-07:00ok mantap sob buat infonya dan salam kenalok mantap sob buat infonya dan salam kenalindowlatotohttp://indowlatoto.winnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-21257341333295173592019-10-24T06:29:32.111-07:002019-10-24T06:29:32.111-07:00Menarik sekali, perlu saya coba ini..
kebetulan la...Menarik sekali, perlu saya coba ini..<br />kebetulan lagi cara tentang hal ini.kungfu4d2http://kungfu4d2.ccnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-76388598308529058222019-10-24T06:28:41.766-07:002019-10-24T06:28:41.766-07:00Mau mendapatkan pelayanan yang baik dan ramah???
...Mau mendapatkan pelayanan yang baik dan ramah???<br /><br />Modal Kecil bisa mendapatkan hasil yg luar biasa...dingdongtogelhttp://dingdongtogel.ccnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-25825660731477233802019-10-24T06:27:49.952-07:002019-10-24T06:27:49.952-07:00sengangat terus ngeblognya mazz..sengangat terus ngeblognya mazz..majutotohttp://majutoto.ccnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-81505191989799564902019-10-23T20:02:38.164-07:002019-10-23T20:02:38.164-07:00Kabar Baik Untuk Para pencinta Game
Karena di Bula...Kabar Baik Untuk Para pencinta Game<br />Karena di Bulan januari ini Sudah keluar Game RPG Online Terpopuler Se-Asia<br />Penasarankan Game nya Seperti apa???<br />Kalian bisa dilihat game nya dari link di bawah yaaatotojituhttp://totojitusgp.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-44746525603360592422017-03-07T22:53:33.491-08:002017-03-07T22:53:33.491-08:00Hello there Tony, Thank you for posting this inter...Hello there Tony, Thank you for posting this interesting analysis. Another piece of musical history. When you are ready come inside Bob Dylan's Music Box http://thebobdylanproject.com/Song/id/620/Tangled-Up-in-Blue and listen to every version of every song.David George Freemanhttp://thebobdylanproject.com/Song/id/620/Tangled-Up-in-Bluenoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-13595422238000719582014-12-04T11:53:17.916-08:002014-12-04T11:53:17.916-08:00My ex-wife said of the NY sessions version of this...My ex-wife said of the NY sessions version of this song: 'every time I hear it, it's like I hear it for the first time'.<br /><br />So true. Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-40058104988302674252013-09-18T15:08:27.851-07:002013-09-18T15:08:27.851-07:00Your point about circular narrative, probably the ...Your point about circular narrative, probably the best one you make in the piece, is very interesting as it relates partly to why Dylan chose to employ such a shattered timescale in this song. I imagine most Dylan biographers are aware of the influence that Norman Reuben had on Dylan's career, and it is in fact in this song that his influence is best shown (outside of Dylan's paintings of course). <br /><br />Reuben had a interesting take on a Cubist, or specifically Braque and Picasso idea that painting an object from different angles on the same canvas could produce a projection of the object, that was more true, more essential than the plain reality. Why this is relevant is the Reuben applied the same concept, expect instead of angle he used time. So he would begin to paint at one point in the day, under a certain light, then later on, maybe at night, or maybe a month later when his mindset was different and had a new way of viewing his subject. At this point I'm sure that most of you can see the similarities this technique has with Tangled Up in Blue and indeed most of the songs on Blood on the Tracks (Simple Twist of Fate, Lily, Rose and the Jack of Hearts spring to mind) as they all appear to jump around in term of time and mood before settling on one single interpretation (i.e the finished canvas). Dylan has always had a close relationship to art throughout his work, but i think it is here that the influence of his painting becomes so interesting.Please Mrs Henrynoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-87863743196032352952013-09-18T14:54:50.976-07:002013-09-18T14:54:50.976-07:00I would just like to point you in the direction of...I would just like to point you in the direction of something i've noticed on "Buckets of Rain" before (or if) you write your next post on it. At the absolute final seconds of that song, Dylan exhales the weariest, most sorrowful syllable, not audible enough to be a sigh, but just audible enough to notice. The purpose of this noise is rather obvious in light of the whole album but i thought it would be worthy of a mention on your blog so more people can hear the way Dylan rounds off one of his masterpieces.Temptation less it runsnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-85675306403889493612013-03-14T10:55:58.938-07:002013-03-14T10:55:58.938-07:00Excellent piece. Isn't there an alternative ly...Excellent piece. Isn't there an alternative lyric (in a live version, or something) when he sings, "We just saw her from a different point of view"? If you apply that idea to the song, the woman becomes the absent centre of the story, and the different narratives are of different men recalling how they met/split from the same woman at different times in her life. That's a nice interpretation too, I think.Gronkhttp://gronk.co.uknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-41727361404806283492011-12-14T16:05:14.838-08:002011-12-14T16:05:14.838-08:00Uh Yeah -
Look, I have mixed feelings about not o...Uh Yeah -<br /><br />Look, I have mixed feelings about not only this exercise in hero worship & adulation of his words but also the over-analyzing of those words as contrasted with what was going on in his life and how it all tied together, so forth & so on. That said, I find it encouraging that folks who were probably not even born when "Blood on the Tracks" was released are discussing it today. <br /><br />My cousin turned me on to "Freewheelin'" in late 1963 while I was in 9th grade & from that point forward I eagerly awaited the next album. I say this not to attempt to acquire some higher status based upon the "I was there when" syndrome but to just say I come at this subject from a different perspective. Kinda like the quote you used above:<br /><br />"We always did feel the same<br />We just saw it from a different point of view."<br /><br />I will agree that many of my contemporaries viewed Dylan in just the way you put it - the strange voice (but he famously proclaimed to a reported at the time that he thought he sounded like Caruso) & the weird songs. Many just didn't get it back then due to the music, the times; perhaps, less so today now that he's recognized as he is, times & tastes have become more sophisticated, people have moved on from their frozen positions. To use another quote from the song:<br /><br />"All the people we used to know<br />They’re an illusion to me now<br />Some are mathematicians<br />Some are carpenters’ wives<br />Don’t know how it all got started<br />I don’t know what they’re doin’ with their lives"<br /><br /><br />Anyway, I can't agree that "Blood on the Tracks" is his best album & strongly disagree that "Tangled Up in Blue" is his best song or even the best song on the album. Personally, I think "Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts" is the best song on the album, closely followed by "Shelter From the Storm." I've always thought that a short film in the style of "Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid" put together with jump cuts that exactly followed the action of "Lily, Rosemary..." would be a great project. <br /><br />As to the meaning of "Tangled..." - have you ever given any consideration that the song seems disjointed simply because it is not a story of a man & a woman's history but rather unrelated incidents from Dylan's life that merely illustrated the type of situations typified by the title?<br /><br />I appreciate what you are doing with this blog but I wonder if you've never watched "No Direction Home" or "Don't Look Back" (yes I'm sure you have - that was rhetorical) because two scenes come to mind: <br /><br />First, Joan Baez talking about how Bob could go way deep & would play a song in 4/4 time one day & then as a waltz the next just to fuck you up, i.e. there's no predicting him.<br />Second, A reporter asks Bob what his song(s) mean and he smirkingly replies disingenuosly, "I don't know what they mean, I just write them." Putting folks on is his speciality.<br /><br />As far as best song - we all have our favorites, subjectivity rules, but I could never agree to "Tangled Up in Blue" as even being in the top 10, let alone being ahead of "Chimes of Freedom" or "Gates of Eden" or "My Back Pages" or even "Visions of Johanna."Wherevernoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-52326250202766814432011-11-17T21:07:23.317-08:002011-11-17T21:07:23.317-08:00Been looking forward to this, thanks for keepin...Been looking forward to this, thanks for keepin' on.Davidnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-21450459339923114062011-11-05T09:10:11.349-07:002011-11-05T09:10:11.349-07:00Thanks for continuing.Thanks for continuing.Jensnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-10351873268335444382011-11-01T08:48:36.368-07:002011-11-01T08:48:36.368-07:00Whaaaaat a post man. The elderly statesman of musi...Whaaaaat a post man. The elderly statesman of music has collided with forms ranging from folk to glam rock and many in between and has left them richer, altered forever. In every endeavour he opened new gates and redefined what can be treated as art. Dylan the unquestionable ‘poet laureate’ of the rock started with folk and transcended the form by owning it. He lent poetic nuances to the protest movement that was shrieking around him in early sixties. He was the reluctant hero who was seen as the voice of his times. Since then he has been conducting a ceaseless and successful campaign to break one rock archetype after another.<br />http://modernartists.blogspot.com/2011/10/bob-dylan-at-70-once-more-for-simple.htmlDhirajhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15724876381617571938noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-47911564861550802342011-11-01T05:46:24.757-07:002011-11-01T05:46:24.757-07:00A while ago my understanding of Dylan's art wa...A while ago my understanding of Dylan's art was entrenched in what you wrote about the songs, his lyrics, the singing – your experience. They were blogposts pregnant with eyes and ears and internal turmoil. Offering a point of view, that made the music, the words, the singing, the sounds more interesting. A blog post became a reason to dug up the art, and get lost into it the arts in a lovely way, that art is presumably made for. Which says something about your writing too. Hopefully the compliment is an inspiration. “Don’t let me wait too long, ‘cause you know how to lay it down.” You’re back. Right?<br /><br />1) <br />Your appreciation of Blood on the Tracks is obvious. You’re right. What can one write about this awesome piece of art and music that might attract readers and raise an eyebrow, or make readers put on the disc and hear it again. Just not an ‘i’-version, but the real one, that moves the body, the heart, the soul. Flac just won’t do.<br /><br />2)<br />I like your observation that Tangled Up in Blue is the six-minute trailer icon for Blood on Tracks. Not sure whether you’re right, the cohesiveness of the album is fascinating. Tangled up in Blue is part of the whole picture, not an iconic summary. Yet I won’t ever be able to erase from my mind your proposed position of Tangled up Blue in the tableau called Blood on the Tracks. But to experience Tangled up in Blue as an entry point and not an integral part of Blood on the Tracks makes Blood on the Tracks less attractive. It is less an iconic six-minute trailer than… overture, or what? <br /><br />3) <br />Your elaborations on Dylan’s work are interesting and a good place for referring new fans to, or those that want to gain a better understanding of Dylan’s art.<br />Here, willingly, knowingly or maybe none of it applies, you depict a quality of Dylan’s poetic work that is typical for what he was learning… or was it unlearning to mix perspectives of time and place. <br /><br />“I like to think of the song as a jumbled-up narrative, one not meant to be taken at face value (…), signposts in telling a Tale of Lost Love (…) are thrown all over the place. It might not make a lot of sense, but it's more fun that way.<br /><br />And, in a strange way, more honest.”<br /><br /><br />If I’m right Dylan has explained his artistic mentor, by accident, Norman Raeben, showed him by example Dylan wasn’t able to paint a vase he had just observed - “I started drawing it and I couldn’t remember shit about this vase.” Tangled up in blue indeed, his thoughts and associations were all over the place, preventing him from seeing what is or was. <br />Maybe one of the reason why the Drawn Blank series might be closer to his own observations than the copy cat photo paintings of the Brasil and Asia series. <br />To me it is not a problem Dylan’s verse seems to come from a mind ‘Tangled up in Blue’ that is producing observations that come across honest, indeed, and make a lot of sense to me. “Time Out of Mind”, “Love and Theft” and “Modern Times” are a welcome outcome.<br /><br />Dylan does mix storylines, perspectives, times and places like not too many of his peers can. While tangled up in blue Dylan does it well. The title of the song is observant of the state of Dylan’s own art – at least the way he had learned to see it.Rob Geurtsennoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-45854346561164242312011-10-31T09:53:44.109-07:002011-10-31T09:53:44.109-07:00Sir Christopher Wren/St Paul's Cathedral
The ...Sir Christopher Wren/St Paul's Cathedral<br /><br />The epitaph on the wall above is very similar to the one on the floor of the Cathedral under the Dome: it ends with the Latin words which are usually translated: 'Reader, if you seek his memorial - look around you.'<br /><br />Posthumous recognition is preferable for greatness if only for the merciful avoidance of seeing the results of one's work.Pat Shuffnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-64614561340647153042011-10-31T04:05:45.685-07:002011-10-31T04:05:45.685-07:00Keep on. It´s certainly a thrillKeep on. It´s certainly a thrillfreeware and mushroomshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05630589460759799548noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-43014641829578573172011-10-31T04:04:46.721-07:002011-10-31T04:04:46.721-07:00I too am glad that you're back on track. It´s ...I too am glad that you're back on track. It´s wonderful to see it , <br />it´s cetainly a thrill.<br /><br />Keep on pressing....freeware and mushroomshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05630589460759799548noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-72015194432297772482011-10-30T13:44:22.557-07:002011-10-30T13:44:22.557-07:00I'll reiterate what Mr. E said- it's great...I'll reiterate what Mr. E said- it's great to see you posting again. <br /><br />Good post; your analysis of the song sounds about right to me. I was wondering what you think of the many changes to lyrics he made during live performances over the years (most obviously the Real Live version). While I don't think there's a version to match the live one, I always find the change in perspective and lines like 'we always saw <i>her</i> from a different point of view' to be rather intriguing...Nick Garlandhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15991335572647619989noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2448601238585270507.post-42730949171796300182011-10-30T07:08:32.380-07:002011-10-30T07:08:32.380-07:00I'm thrilled the blog is back. I hope the next...I'm thrilled the blog is back. I hope the next break won't be quite so long.Mr. E.https://www.blogger.com/profile/15385574818124792046noreply@blogger.com